Pages

Sunday, March 3, 2013

School Safety

I am conflicted, and so I will think out loud with you.  I have been asked to develop proposals to make our schools safer and submit them to the Board for approval.  We have held two workshops and consulted law enforcement and I still struggle.  This is why I struggle.
Just like after Columbine, we are spending a lot of time and thought and thinking about spending a lot of money to enhance school safety after the tragedy in Newton, Connecticut.  And as always, I wonder if this is what we should be doing.  So, I decided to crunch a few numbers (I know, this will be referred to as my math period.) 
There are 132,656 schools in the U.S. including public, private and charter1.  Most schools serve kids on a 180 day instructional year.  So, we have 132,656 x 180 = 23,878,080 instructional days per year in our country.  Three years would be 71,634,240 days (23,878,080 x 3.)  With me so far?
In the past 3 years there have been 27 incidents of active shooters on school campuses.  These incidents resulted in death and/or injury.  I used 3 years because the data varies from 9 to 16 incidents during those years, so this appeared to be a safe way mathematically to talk about risky behavior.
So, the question is how likely is any one school to experience an active shooter during any given school year?  The answer is 27 incidents ÷ 71,634,240 school days = .00000037, or .000037%.  Since probabilities range from 0 to 1, this is a very low probability.  To determine the odds of this happening we would divide .00000037 by 1-.00000037 and get an answer that looks like .00000037 ÷.99999963 = .00000037, or the odds of this happening are 1 in 3.7 million.  (I am not a math whiz, so if I made errors please tell me.)
Interesting.  The odds of getting struck by lightning are 1 in 1 million.  The odds of a large asteroid, a planet killer known as 2011 AGS, hitting earth in the year 2040 are 1 in 625.  The odds of getting hurt playing high school football are 1 in 2.85 (with 1 million players and 350,000 injuries per year2).  And yet, we are spending an incredible amount of time and energy seeking ways to make our schools safer.  School superintendents and school boards everywhere are holding meetings, consulting law enforcement and safety experts to develop new and enhanced safety plans so their schools will not be a Newton or a Columbine.  Clearly, we want our schools to be safe places.
They are safe!  There are few places safer than schools.  Kids are more likely to get hurt if we let them drive, play football, or be a cheerleader than going to school and being shot by someone on campus.  It is more risky to fly on an airline than to go to school.  It is more risky to take a cruise than to go to school.  It is more risky to be a poor African American male in an urban setting than to go to school.  One could easily argue that schools are so safe any tinkering with the fundamental safety model may make schools less safe. 
I happen to believe that some of the new safety enhancements being enacted by some school districts will forever change the campus climate and in fact make schools more risky.  Adding a law enforcement officer to a school may make it safer in the short run, but will not help kids believe that we adults in the system really care about them.  It is tough enough for some students to deal with compulsory attendance without having to arrive on campus and find an armed officer on duty.  I think that contributes to the resentment kids have for school and in the long run contributes more to possible violence.  We must rely on kids in a mutually trusting environment to tell us what is brewing on campus and in the minds of other students.  This will not help.
Allowing adults to transport and maintain weapons on campus is not likely, IMHO, to make the school safer.  I think it will make the school less safe.  All the arguments regarding an armed faculty serving as a deterrent to school shootings assumes the active shooter adheres to logic and does not want to die himself.  (I say “him” because few females engage in this behavior.)  It is not like I wake up one morning, decide I am going to take my legally purchased semi automatic assault rifle to a school and kill kids and staff and then die myself in a blaze of glory, but I won’t go to this school because a teacher has a gun in a lockbox or hidden on their belt.  That reasoning is seriously flawed.
Yes, we have security and emergency plans, and yes, we need to review and update those plans.  Yes, we need to be sure that all the adults know what to do in time of crisis.  Yes, we have security cameras everywhere.  Yes, we need to be alert to people on our campuses that do not belong there.  Yes, we need to continue to pay attention to the safety of the children in our care.  The odds are, however, more of them will be hurt participating in our athletic programs than by an active shooter.  I do not want to take any steps that make campuses more risky using the argument we need more security.
The shooting at Newton remains a deep tragedy.  Same is true of Columbine.  We should remain alert; we should faithfully conduct fire drills, tornado drills, lockdown drills, etc.  We should not dramatically change the school climate to prevent an incident that is very unlikely to occur, especially when some of the strategies are likely to increase the violence at schools.  Unless we build fences around our schools, have one entry point with metal detectors and an armed guard, then we are not likely to really enhance school safety.  I do not believe any of us want that.  I believe schools are safe.  The data supports that.  In my community of 6,000 good souls and 1,500 students we are very quick to recognize someone askew on our premises.
On the other hand, our community seems to want us to do something, implement some strategy that will guarantee the safety of our kids.  They see other districts implementing all kinds of strategies from officers on campus, staff with guns, panic buttons, security cameras, etc.  We should respond to those concerns.  Telling our public, our parents, that their kids are safe already is little comfort for those who fear the worst.  In fact, all that we are currently doing does not guarantee student safety.  I am not sure we can ever guarantee that.  But, what should we do?
I remain conflicted.

1.      National Center for Education Statistics, http://nces.ed.gov

2.      Risk Factors for Injury in High School Football Players, Sean D. Turbeville,*† PhD, Linda D. Cowan,* PhD, Willis L. Owen,* PhD, Nabih R. Asal,§ PhD, and Mark A. Anderson,‡ PhD, From the *Department of Biostatistics and Epidemiology, College of Public Health, and the Department of Physical Therapy and Rehabilitative Sciences, College of Allied Health, University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, and the §Department of Health Policy and Epidemiology, College of Medicine, University of Florida,Gainesville, Florida). 

6 comments:

  1. As would I be, and am, Bob....in discussing these very matters with kids,believe it or not at the end of it all, the majority of them said, "But this is Edna...why are we worried?". It should be a comfort at least to know that they feel relatively safe. Their fears lie within the social realm, of course. True, we can't let the tragic events leave us unfazed and indifferent to the matter, when the the ideas have all been hashed there is no clear cut answer; and to what extent and EXPENSE should we go? Sacrifice a teacher for an officer? We live in a small town, our cops are close enough already, no? I saw a bumper sticker once that read: "You can't fix stupid." Well, how much simpler can you get? Any and all measures you and the board my valiantly take could ultimately be all for naught when "stupid" arrives and is on a mission to hurt, destroy , or kill. So your challenge is great my friend, I pray for you in the decision making process with which you have been charged...

    "Fearing people is a dangerous trap, but trusting the Lord means safety." Proverbs 29:25 NLT

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I am pleased that kids feel safe, and I totally agree about police response time and the risk of sacrificing needed instructional resources for security. Mostly, I am very grateful for your insight, your sharing and your friendship. Thanks, Sarah

      Delete
  2. Again I like your math. The idea around school safety is that all kids are important and that it would be a tragedy if even one student lost their life while on a school campus. Using that line of thinking - it would be a tragedy if even one child failed to reach their full potential because of a changed school climate to one that was perceived to be more like a prison. As an educator I take the safety of my students and fellow staff members very personally and will pursue wise measures to ensure their safety. Here I do not see the educational need to pursue a SRO type position within Edna ISD. It would be a waste of scarce resources.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree. However, we are a public school and must remain responsive to our public. How do we do that and continue to implement the best instructional program we can? I am not sure we can simply do nothing on this topic. I remain conflicted.

      Delete
    2. I think you are going about this in the correct manner. You have investigated and are continuing to invetigate options. You are discussing it with district leaders and moving towards a remedy to offer the board. You value the safety of childeren both physically and more important, mentally. I think if the community looked at the numbers - approximately $175,000 to $250,000 in intial costs and approximately $100,000 to $150,000 in annul operating costs - that will end up serving approximately 25% of Edna ISD's student population (the SRO will be housed at the HS I assume). His response time to the elementary or junior high may not be any better than that of the Edna PD or Jackson County Sheriffs office. Those figures would equate to new teachers, administrators, computers, and other services or programs that would be of a more tangible benefit to the students of Edna ISD. I appluad you for your desire to earnestly listen to your community and look for the best means to address a problem. And also for the time to listen to others' (mine included)opinions.

      Delete
  3. School safety is major issue today. Lot of agencies gave service of safety and security after hiring. School Safety

    ReplyDelete