Pages

Tuesday, February 6, 2018

Believing Falsehoods


I am a Star Trek fan, and one of my favorite episodes was the 8th episode in the 3rd season, “For the World is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky.”  As a planet is on the verge of dying the humanoids there build an asteroid to launch their species into space.  From inside the asteroid it appears that the survivors are standing on the surface of a planet looking at the sky, so after generations in space the humanoids do not know they are inside a fabricated asteroid controlled by a computer hurtling through the cosmos.  But one elder member of the group, just before his death, confesses to Captain Kirk that he knows the truth. “For the world is hollow and I have touched the sky.”  Only he knew the real truth.  Only he knew the others suffered from a perception they believed to be true.

This notion of perception is repeated throughout all kinds of literature.  The Emperor’s New Clothes is a classic fairy tale about a king who believes he is wearing gorgeous garments when in fact he is naked and only a young child is willing to challenge the universal perception.  Plato’s Republic recounts an anecdote where men are chained to a wall in a cave and can only see their shadows on the opposite wall.  They come to believe the shadows are real.  One man escapes, makes it to the surface and understands that what they have been seeing is just shadows, not reality.  He returns to the cave but fails to convince his peers of the truth.

Joel Barker, futurist, describes in his video, “The Business of Paradigms” how the Swiss, who manufactured most of the watches in the world, rejected the design of the first digital watch because it did not exhibit the attributes they believed were critical for a timepiece.  It had no gears, no springs, no face, no hands.  The Swiss loss their preeminence in the market as the Japanese bought the rights to the watch the Swiss rejected and began to mass produce digital watches.

We are in the middle of such a time in America.  There are groups of Americans who base their decision-making, their support, their view of the world on falsehoods, naked kings, shadows and erroneous paradigms.  As long as those among us remain committed to viewing the world through false lenses we are in serious trouble.  It is as though I awakened one morning to discover that about 35% of American citizens believe Santa Claus is real and Zeus is the Supreme Being.

Worse, to try to convince my peers of the error in their perspective generates hate, vitriolic speech and name calling.  I have lost friends trying to show that their perception is a shadow, not reality.  They so desperately cling to their view that they will continue to stand on the deck of the Titanic convinced the ship cannot sink.  How do we reach these folks?  What logic, what facts will prevail against a belief so totally rooted in falsehoods? 

Perhaps identifying the source of the falsehoods would help. 

Our current President is a compulsive liar beyond anything ever seen.  There are over 2,000 documented lies that he has perpetrated on the American people.  He is not to be believed.  The simple fact that he is waging war on the Justice Department, the FBI, and anyone who may be sharing truth with the collusion and obstruction of justice investigation is the reveal of ill intent, and surely not of democracy.

Fox News has an entertainment charter, not a news charter.  They can say anything they want and not be held accountable because it is “info-tainment.”  They consistently repeat and support the President’s lies.  They are not to be believed.

Russia continues to unleash “bots” or automated social media responses supporting the President and his policies.  Their mission is to destabilize our democracy.  Those posts and tweets are not to be believed.

Sadly, to accept that these sources are false requires a simple fact-check, something the true supporters are not willing to do, so they continue to believe shadows are real and the sky is real.

But it is getting more serious.  Today a reporter was banned from a press conference because he refused to edit an article to be more favorable to the Trump administration.  That is unheard of in a democracy.  If what is reported is false, then there are all kinds of legal ramifications and consequences.  But to censor a reporter because he is not “loyal” is not a democratic practice.

The same with a host of previous appointed officials now unemployed.  If one is an official in the Justice Department one pledges allegiance and loyalty to the Constitution and the law of the land, not to an elected President.  Loyalty to an elected person as the only criteria for maintaining your job is a 3rd World practice, not a democratic practice.

If our nation is no longer based on the Constitution, on law, on the checks and balances of the three branches of government, and on the protection of civil liberties including a free press and free speech, then we no longer qualify as a democracy.  So I literally beg those of you who continue to support this man to do two things.  One, get your news from somewhere other than Fox, Brietbart and the like.  And fact-check everything the President or his spokespeople say.  If that does not convince you that you have grown to believe shadows are real then I see little hope for our democracy to survive.  I believe in my heart of hearts that the truth will win out over the lies and that justice will prevail over conspiracy.  But the more of us who believe and constantly check reality better off we will be.

If it helps, I did not feel this way when either Bush was President, or Ford or Reagan or Nixon.  Just Trump.

Please abandon the falsehoods for truth.


No comments:

Post a Comment