As my frustration with things political and economic grows,
and as I always feel I am on the cusp of a rant, I wonder how so many around me
remain happy, at ease, and content. I am
not sure, but I have a theory. I look
closely at the areas of my greatest angst and wonder how I might release those
feelings to achieve a state of daily bliss.
Perhaps if I believed the following I would be happier:
If I believed that the wealthy in our country not only had a
right to be wealthy bestowed upon them as almost a divine right, they have a
right to increase their wealth even at the expense of the poor, I might be
happier. I should absolve the wealthy of
all notions of responsibility for others.
I should argue that promoting the accumulation of wealth in the hands of
a few somehow benefits those who are most needy. If I believed that, I would feel less angst.
If I believed that our nation was founded on Christian
beliefs and that the purpose of government is to enact law that promotes
Christianity, especially certain conservative versions of Christianity that
view homosexuality as sinful, same sex marriage as blasphemy, and that females
should not have a voice or choice in their ability to reproduce, I might be
happier. I should argue that the state
has both the authority and the purpose to promote this form of belief, that
there should be staff led prayer in schools, there should be Christian symbols
at public buildings, Christians of my ilk should be allowed to discriminate
against those with a different sexual orientation, and if push comes to shove,
that Anglos are superior to other races, and males are superior to
females. If I believed that, I would
feel less angst.
If I believed the Bible was not only the literal truth, but
that the book should serve as a superior resource to science for our understanding
of our world, I might be happier. I would
argue that the earth is 6,000 years old, that Darwinism is a flawed assumption,
that there was no big bang, that God created the universe in 6 days, that
humans and dinosaurs co-existed on the planet, that women should submit to
their husbands, that God blesses the wealthy, and that the poor and the victims
of disaster and violence must have sinned in some way. I would argue that what we believe is more
valid than what we know. If I believed
that, I would feel less angst.
If I believed that our government was in fact our enemy and
should be curtailed as much as possible, I might be happier. If I oppose all governmental intervention in
the private sector, I should argue that there should be virtually no
regulations controlling businesses, especially Wall Street, banks, environmental
pollutes, safety in the workplace and fossil fuel companies. I should further argue that discrimination in
the private sector is OK, paying workers the least amount possible is OK,
denying workers expensive benefits is OK, and that forces that work against
such beliefs such as unions should be abolished. If I believed that, I would feel less angst.
If I believed that global warming was a myth; more, that if
there is global warming human behavior has not influenced such warming, I might
be happier. I should argue that this is
merely a historical cycle and has nothing to do with consumption of fossil fuels
and has nothing to do with deforestation, etc.
I would further argue that any governmental effort to curtail possible
human influence on the environment is a clear example of government over reach
in the private sector. The pursuit of
profit is more important than the environment.
If I believed that, I would feel less angst.
If I believed that America’s public schools are a huge
failure, a source of incredible wasteful spending of huge amounts of tax
dollars, and lacking the components of the private sector, I might be
happier. I should argue that any
strategy that makes public schools look bad such as standardized high stakes
testing, labeling schools A to F, holding teachers and schools accountable for
student test scores, is a good thing because it helps reduce funding for public
schools and promotes shifting tax dollars to the private sector via charters
and vouchers. I should argue there is
something inherently wrong with a system of adults who perform public service
for children and are immune to a sense of competition, incentives to increase income,
and seek to perform more as professionals than technicians. Such a group is very scary and market forces
must be implemented in the school systems to warp them. I should also argue that the most important
function of public education should be to promote the status quo and support
the beliefs outlined above. Schools
should never teach students to think critically, to look at problems from
multiple angles and to question what we know and what we do. Any such effort should be quickly
squashed. Further, if we find a public
school employee who does not adhere to these beliefs they are dangerous and
must be removed. If I believed that, I
would feel less angst.
I guess those are the main areas that are causing me such
angst. If I could just adopt those
beliefs outlined above I would be happier, I think. Should I adopt those beliefs I would find
myself surrounded by like thinkers, I would find myself in the majority (at least
in Texas), and I would celebrate the efforts of the current state leadership
and national congressional leadership.
Oh, to let myself believe those things.
But: I am the victim
of an education. I learned to read, to
read a variety of sources and a variety of opinions. I learned to think, to systematically analyze
what I read looking for consistency and fact.
In short, I believe I know too much to support any of the above beliefs. My knowledge conflicts with those beliefs and
I when there is conflict, I choose knowledge over belief. Hence my angst.
So I know that every time our nation has moved to promote
wealth accumulation rather than provide a safety net for the poor and working
poor, the economic system has approached collapse. And yet we are doing it again. I know that all those government regulations
exist because the market and profit motive is not ethical. Producers can make more money if they sell
goods and services that may harm consumers or harm the employees. When we have allowed producers to operate
without government oversight we have faced terrible consequences for our well-being. I know that our founding fathers were deathly
afraid that our government would endorse or support one religion over another
and took great care to separate the function of the government from any belief
system. I know that global warming is
not a myth, and human influence on the warming is not a myth. We helped create the current crisis by pursuing
profit over well-being and the long term health of our planet. I know that the Bible is not a science
textbook and I would no more look to it for scientific understanding than I
would look to it for help with a computer virus or to tune the engine of my car. I know the universe is about 14 billion years
old and that planet earth is about 4.5 billion years old. I know that dinosaurs were on the planet from
about 230 million years ago until 65 million years ago. I know that the great apes, including humans,
first evolved about 15 million years ago, that modern humans evolved about 1
million to 500,000 years ago. No way is
the planet 6,000 years old, no way dinosaurs and humans co-existed, and no way
that evolution is not valid.
And I know that American public schools are doing great,
thank you very much. We are doing great
despite the ongoing assault of the private sector to prove otherwise. Each of the experiments developed by
billionaires has failed; each of the efforts to divert public dollars to
private efforts has shown no improvement, and each of the efforts to increase
accountability has in fact pushed our education system in the wrong direction
for selfish reasons.
I cannot forget what I know.
I cannot suddenly believe the sun rotates around the earth and that the
earth is the center of the universe when I know so much more. The beliefs that seem to be the majority in
public opinion are for the most part wrong, misinformed or blatant lies. I do believe that men and women of conscience
must speak out against such false beliefs.
And I know that as long as I do not believe and speak out I
will not live in a state of daily bliss.
That’s OK. I firmly believe the
knowledge revolution is here and growing and that in the long run knowledge
will win over conflicting beliefs. It
always has and always will. In that I do
find some happiness.
Wow, again you have taken the thoughts from my mind and put them to paper or cyberspace. They are also the thoughts of my husband, several of my family members and even several of my friends( although the percentage of friends who think this way would be about 30%)
ReplyDeleteI had often thought that these people who call themselves CHRISTIAN, CONSERVATIVE, PATRIOTS, Perfect Thinking Folks with FAMILY VALUES who know the appropriate Bible verse for every belief ( I run on)
live in a state of utter euphoria, thinking that they have found true bliss in life.
Evidently, there can be another side to this coin, Bob.
The other evening, my husband and I were out for a walk in our shady, tree lined, well landscaped neighborhood filled with comfortable,( most remodeled with granite counter tops), 30 year old brick homes inhabited by mostly kind conservative folk who have either retired here as their last home, or maybe a few new young families who are starting the second generation.
An elderly, bent over man approached us along the sidewalk walking his dog. We exchanged niceties and he stopped to chat - we did remember that he lived about 5 houses away and my husband remembered that he had lived on the street for many years. He suddenly asked us what we thought was going to happen to this country with Obama trying to ruin it and the gays and Muslims all taking over!
" I am really worried !" he said, as he nodded his head and looked at the ground. He went on to tell us that he was a retired petroleum engineer for Phillips and had graduated from A&M. We remained silent, smiling and telling him to enjoy the evening and bragging about his cute little dog. We have a friend who answers folks like this with a gloom and doom outlook in this way, " It seems like you've been watching too much FOX News!"
We go to church groups where it is prayed that something can be done about" that Obama and his people". Several friends regularly post on facebook that the end of the world must be near! Maybe we are the ones living in bliss. It is a thought.
Really good point, Dinah. Perhaps the conservatives who live in fear and anger are miserable as well. My hope for them is that they read, think, explore. Education must be the source of enlightenment.
ReplyDelete